cfDNA sequencing for fetal aneuploidy may detect chromosomal abnormalities representative of maternal malignancy.
Maternal malignancy must be considered when abnormal cfDNA sequencing for fetal aneuploidy is associated with normal fetal karyotype.
Recently, cell-free plasma DNA (cfDNA) sequencing for fetal aneuploidy has become the standard method for screening women at high risk for fetal aneuploidy and is now increasingly applied in low-risk pregnancies. Here, we present a case where a focal, chromosome arm-level gain on chromosome 21 detected via cfDNA screening did not reflect fetal aneuploidy, but in fact, represented the molecular driver of the patient’s subsequently diagnosed iAMP21 B-cell acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). This report highlights a technological evolution in maternal medicine that is of increasing relevance to hematologists and oncologists who may need to investigate possible cases of maternal malignancy.
A 21-year-old woman with a history of α-thalassemia trait was referred by her obstetrician during her first pregnancy for a hematologic evaluation because of a persistent, mild pancytopenia. At the time of referral, the patient was at 26 weeks of gestation and was noted to have a leukocytosis with circulating blasts, anemia, and thrombocytopenia with clinical concern for acute leukemia. She was transferred to our center for further management.
Upon presentation, a complete blood count revealed a white blood cell count of 13.1 × 109/L with 68% blasts, hemoglobin of 7.6 g/dL, and a platelet count of 35 × 109/L. Flow cytometry of peripheral blood demonstrated an immature population positive for CD45 (dim), CD34, HLA-DR, CD123 (dim), TdT, and the B-lymphoid markers CD10, CD19, CD20 (variable), and CD22. The immature cells were negative for T lymphoid, myeloid, and monocytic markers. This pattern was consistent with a diagnosis of B-cell ALL. A bone marrow biopsy revealed a hypercellular marrow with 94% of the cellularity composed of small- to intermediate-sized blasts.
Genetic characterization of the leukemia was notable for a complex karyotype 46,X,add(X)(p22.1),del(9)(p21),add(10)(q25),-21,+mar[cp19]/46,XX. Our institution’s 95-gene hematologic malignancy-focused targeted DNA sequencing panel1 revealed an insertion in IL7R (p.L242_L243delinsFGLRGCP) as well as mutations in CSF3R (p.809fs*) and LUC7L2 (p.R205*). Read count analysis (Figure 1A) was significant for loss of IKZF1 (on 7p), loss of CTCF (16q), multiple copy gain of RUNX1 (21q), deletion of U2AF1 (21q), as well as gain of CRLF2, PIGA, ZRSR2, and BCOR (all on Xp). In addition, a P2RY8-CRLF2 fusion was detected in bone marrow RNA via a multiplex polymerase chain reaction assay. Metaphase fluorescence in situ hybridization analysis confirmed amplification of RUNX1 (estimated 10 copies per cell; Figure 1B). In sum, these genetic findings are consistent with a diagnosis of iAMP21 B-cell ALL (based on the multiple additional RUNX1 copies), a provisional entity in the World Health Organization classification of acute leukemia.2-4
After diagnosis of B-cell ALL, it was recognized that the patient had undergone routine prenatal cfDNA screening (QNatal Advanced, Quest Diagnostics) from a maternal blood sample drawn ∼14 weeks prior, at 12 weeks and 2 days of gestation. A complete blood count ∼4 weeks prior to cfDNA screening showed mild leukopenia (white blood cell count of 2.9 × 109/L with normal differential) without anemia, thrombocytopenia, or abnormal cells. The test had returned an indeterminate result for chromosome 21 prompting an amniocentesis, which showed a normal fetal karyotype (46,XX).
Results and discussion
Prenatal cfDNA screening uses massively parallel shotgun sequencing of cfDNA isolated from maternal plasma to detect common fetal aneuploidies of chromosomes 13, 18, 21, X, and/or Y, with a reported sensitivity of >99% and specificity ∼100%.5-7 The positive predictive value of cfDNA screening has been reported to be 98%, 92%, and 69% for trisomies of 21, 18, and 13, respectively.7 This assay takes advantage of the fact that 10% to 20% of the cfDNA in maternal plasma in the late first to early second trimester is derived from fetal tissue, most from placental trophoblastic cells. Despite excellent screening test characteristics, discordant results from cfDNA screens are well recognized. False positive results can be attributed to diverse etiologies, including confined placental mosaicism, cotwin demise, maternal chromosomal mosaicism, maternal organ transplant from a male donor,8-12 and, as in this case, maternal malignancy.13-15 Here, review of the patient’s sequencing confirmed that some of the major genetic alternations documented in her tumor sample, specifically amplification of a limited region of distal chromosome 21 as well as gain of genes on Xp, were detectable in the sequenced cfDNA.
Normalized DNA copy number estimations from the patient’s cfDNA demonstrated an ∼12-Mb amplification of chr21q22 (Figure 1C). This region of amplification is consistent with that seen in iAMP21 B-cell ALL cases3,16 and contains several genes implicated in B-ALL pathogenesis, including RUNX1,17 DYRK1A,18 ERG,19 and HMGN1.20 The specific driver or drivers of leukemogenesis in iAMP21 are not yet clearly defined, but the amplification event is thought to occur via chromothripsis, a phenomenon of extensive genomic rearrangement usually confined to a single chromosome.21 Copy number inference via targeted capture DNA sequencing of ∼400 cancer genes22 from the patient’s diagnostic bone marrow showed amplification of 3 genes on 21q22 (RUNX1, ERG, TMPRSS2; Figure 1A). Gain of Xp was also detected, in a region that included CRLF2, which is often detected in B-cell ALLs with the intrachromosomal P2RY8-CRLF2 fusion.23 P2RY8-CRLF2 rearrangements also frequently cooccur with iAMP21.16
Detection of asymptomatic maternal malignancy during pregnancy by cfDNA screening has been reported.13-15 Bianchi et al described 10 cases of maternal cancer identified by cfDNA screening out of a tested cohort of 125 426 women associated with 3757 positive results (3%).14 Most of the cases associated with maternal cancer (7 of 10) contained the otherwise rare cfDNA finding of ≥2 whole chromosomal aneuploidies. The authors estimated the risk of maternal cancer among women with multiple aneuploidies in cfDNA to be between 20% and 44%.
There are not yet consensus guidelines for identification and management of cfDNA results suggestive of maternal malignancy. Therefore, interpretation of cases with discordant findings between cfDNA results and diagnostic testing for fetal aneuploidy requires expert individualized evaluation. Referral to a genetic counselor with experience evaluating common and uncommon etiologies of false positive cfDNA results is ideal. Communication with the diagnostic laboratory to review the primary sequencing data may provide additional insight, as in this case where trisomy 21 was suspected, but an indeterminate result for chromosome 21 was issued on the cfDNA report.
The association between maternal malignancies and chaotic cfDNA results (ie, multiple aneuploidies) is gaining recognition. Our finding of a single chromosomal abnormality associated with maternal cancer is not well described and may be less likely to raise clinical suspicion for malignancy. However, given the specific association between chromosome 21 and hematologic malignancies, we would propose a heightened suspicion for malignancy in cases of discordant results involving chromosome 21, even if it is the only detected abnormality.
This report illustrates a notable presentation of the uncommon scenario of maternal malignancy during pregnancy. These cases will increase because cfDNA screening is now recommended in all pregnancies at high risk for fetal aneuploidy and is quickly becoming ubiquitous in low-risk pregnancies.5,6,24 Hematologists and oncologists will be called upon more often to investigate cases of possible or confirmed maternal malignancy. In addition, this case is unique in the literature in that a focal, chromosome arm-level copy gain detected on cfDNA screening was representative of a maternal malignancy defined molecularly by that exact DNA abnormality. In this patient, cfDNA screening detected amplification of a limited region of chromosome 21q22, which itself is thought to represent the primary driver of the patient’s disease, iAMP21 B-cell ALL.
Contribution: M.R.L. and A.A.L. wrote the manuscript; M.N.D., S.R.E., P.D.C., R.O., B.I., M.M., and A.A.L. performed diagnostic tests and analyzed the data; and all authors reviewed the manuscript.
Conflicts-of-interest disclosure: R.O., B.I., and M.M. are employees of Quest Diagnostics. The remaining authors declare no competing financial interests.
Correspondence: Marlise R. Luskin, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, 450 Brookline Ave, Dana 2056, Boston, MA 02215; e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.