To the Editor:

With great interest we read the article of Sarfati et al1 dealing with the prognostic impact of the serum levels of soluble CD23 (sCD23) in B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia (B-CLL). The results of their study show that, as expected, the stage of disease at initial presentation of the patient predicts survival, and that the serum levels of sCD23 correlate with the total tumor burden, ie, the involvement of lymph nodes and the involvement of liver and spleen, and with the rate of progression into higher stages of the disease. Interestingly, the authors describe a threshold level of sCD23 of 574 U/mL above that the probability of survival of the patients is adversely affected. The conclusion is drawn that the serum level of sCD23 at first diagnosis is a major risk factor for disease progression and has an impact on overall survival. These results are in accordance with data of our own trial that will be published elsewhere.2 However, the design of the study of Sarfati et al provokes some critical comments.

Survival data from patients diagnosed in 1983 as well as from patients first presented in 1994 were summarized and plotted together. In the meantime, however, the probability of survival within a given risk group has changed, probably due to advances in supportive care. While in 1975 Rai et al3 reported a median survival time of 19 months for patients with stages III and IV disease — corresponding to the 20 months median survival time for patients with stage C disease as published by Binet et al4 in 1981 — the median survival was recorded to be 30 months for the same risk group of patients in 1989.5 In addition, at least since 1990, a proportion of patients may have received treatment with nucleoside analogues which could have influenced the overall outcome.6 Therefore, and because no analysis of the causes of death is given, the survival curves presented by Sarfati et al may be biased essentially and cannot confirm definitely the prognostic importance of sCD23. Also, unfortunately, Sarfati et al were not able to examine any correlation of sCD23 levels with other already known risk factors including the pattern of bone marrow (BM) infiltration,7 the lymphocyte doubling time (LDT),8 and levels of the serum thymidine kinase (sTK).9 In our own trial on newly diagnosed patients with Binet stage A B-CLL a strong correlation between high levels of sCD23 and a diffuse BM infiltration, an LDT ≤ 12 months and an sTK > 5 U/mL was established. Multivariate analysis showed that sCD23 and the LDT were superior over the BM infiltration pattern and sTK levels in predicting progressive disease.2 Thus, we are convinced that the serum level of sCD23 at initial presentation of a patient with early stage B-CLL has a great prognostic impact. However, the study of Sarfati et al contributes only partially to the establishment of sCD23 as a recognized risk factor in B-CLL.

REFERENCES

REFERENCES
1
Sarfati
M
Chevret
S
Chastang
C
Biron
G
Stryckmans
P
Delespesse
G
Binet
J-L
Merle-Beral
H
Bron
D
Prognostic importance of serum soluble CD23 level in chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
Blood
88
1996
4259
2
Knauf WU, Langenmayer I, Ehlers B, Mohr B, Adorf D, Nerl Ch, Hallek M, Zwingers Th, Emmerich B, Thiel E: Serum levels of soluble CD23, but not soluble CD25, predict disease progression in early stage B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Leuk Lymphoma 1997 (in press)
3
Rai
KR
Sawitsky
A
Cronkite
EP
Chanana
AD
Levy
RN
Pasternak
BS
Clinical staging of chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
Blood
46
1975
219
4
Binet
JL
Auquier
A
Dighiero
G
Chastang
C
Piguet
H
Goasguen
J
Vaugier
G
Potron
G
Colona
P
Oberlin
F
Thomas
M
Tchernia
G
Jacquillt
C
Boivin
P
Lesty
C
Dulaut
MT
Monconduit
M
Belabbes
S
Gremy
F
A new prognostic classification of chronic lymphocytic leukemia derived from a multivariate survival analysis.
Cancer
48
1981
198
5
International Workshop on Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (IWCLL)
Chronic lymphocytic leukemia: Recommendations for diagnosis, staging, and response criteria.
Ann Intern Med
110
1989
236
6
Keating
MJ
Kantarjian
H
O'Brien
S
Koller
C
Talpaz
M
Schachner
J
Child
CC
Freireich
EJ
McCredie
KB
Fludarabine: A new agent with marked cytoreductive activity in untreated chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
J Clin Oncol
9
1991
44
7
Rozman
C
Montserrat
E
Rodriguez-Fernandez
JM
Ayats
R
Vallespi
T
Parody
R
Rios
A
Prados
D
Morey
M
Gomis
F
Alcala
A
Guiterrez
M
Maldonado
J
Gonzalez
C
Giralt
M
Hernandez-Nieto
L
Cabrera
A
Fernandez-Rananda
JM
Bone marrow histologic pattern: The best single prognostic parameter in chronic lymphocytic leukemia. A multivariate analysis of 329 cases.
Blood
64
1984
642
8
Montserrat
E
Sanchez-Bisono
J
Vinolas
N
Rozman
C
Lymphocyte doubling time in chronic lymphocytic leukemia: Analysis of its prognostic significance.
Br J Haematol
62
1986
567
9
Källander
C
Simonsson
B
Hagberg
B
Gronowitz
J
Serum deoxythymidine kinase gives prognostic information in chronic lymphocytic leukemia.
Cancer
54
1984
2450