In this issue of Blood, the papers of Aymonnier et al1 on the use of protease nexin 1 and de Maat et al2 on the use of altered α-1-antitrypsin propose therapeutic uses of these serpins for the management of coagulation and contact system disorders, respectively. Serpins are a family of serine protease inhibitors that regulate proteases of plasma, mostly enzymes of blood coagulation, complement, and inflammatory systems.
Interest in serpins as possible therapeutic tools began in 1978, when Lewis et al published a paper about a 10-year-old boy who had an unknown life-long hemorrhagic disorder.3 After his death, an abnormal plasma α-1-antitrypsin (α-1-antitrypsin Pittsburgh [α1AT-Pitt]) was characterized that has a reactive center Met358Arg polymorphism, converting this elastase inhibitor to a thrombin inhibitor (see figure panel A).4 α1AT-Pitt is a tragic event of nature, but therapeutic serpin modification, this commentary’s focus, as in the papers of Aymonnier et al and de Maat et al, has clinical importance. α1AT-Pitt also is a potent inhibitor of plasma kallikrein (PKa), αFXIIa, and βFXIIa.5,6 It anticoagulates simulated cardiopulmonary bypass circuits, but its infusion into septic baboons did not prevent the associated coagulopathy due to in vivo inactivation.
Much recent effort has been made to derive novel treatments for hemophilia by rebalancing the reduced coagulation in hemophilia patients with designer immunoglobulin made to function like the missing factors or immunoglobulin or other inhibitors to regulate hemostasis (see figure panel B). Emicizumab is a monoclonal antibody that binds FIXa/IX and FX/Xa to function like FVIII/FVIIIa in patients with hemophilia A or inhibitors to FVIII.7 Monoclonal antibodies to TFPI (eg, concizumab, PF-06741086, Bayer 1093884) rebalance hemostasis by allowing more factor VIIa–tissue factor complex to activate factor X directly.8 In addition, forms of factor X less susceptible to antithrombin inhibition (zymogen-like FXa [I16L]) have been produced to bypass a hemophilia block or coagulation protein inhibitor.9
Lessons learned from α1AT-Pitt also have been applied to hemophilia rebalancing. If one has FVIII or FIX deficiency, lowering antithrombin with a siRNA (fitusiran) rebalances the hemostatic defect (see figure panel B).10 Altering α1AT by substituting a Lys and Arg in the P2 and P1 positions, respectively, and a Lys in the P1′ spot (see figure panel A) changes α1AT into an improved activated protein C inhibitor that reduces thrombin inhibition and, presumably, improves hemostasis.11 Like α1AT-Pitt, the Arg in the P1 position makes it a serine protease target, but the Lys in the P2 and P1′ position prevents the reactive center from thrombin interference.
In this issue of Blood, a novel approach to hemophilia rebalancing via a serpin is presented. Protease nexin-1 (PN-1) has specificity toward thrombin. Very early PN-1 was recognized on the activated platelet surface in complex with thrombin.12 Aymonnier and colleagues observed that platelet PN-1 deficiency in activated f8−/− platelets or PN-1 inhibition in platelet-rich plasma from severe hemophilia patients significantly improved thrombin generation. In murine models, combined f8−/−/Serpine2−/− (PN-1 knockouts) mice have reduced blood loss and bleeding times compared with f8−/− mice alone.1 Neutralizing antibody to PN-1 enhances clot stability and lengthens clot lysis time on thromboelastometry in blood from f8−/−/Serpine2−/− mice and hemophilia A patients. These data indicate that removal of PN-1 from plasma or platelet-rich plasma produces increased thrombin generation. Because PN-1’s target is thrombin, an end point in the hemostatic pathway, its inhibition additionally may be applicable to correct hemostasis in hemophilia B and factor XI deficiency (hemophilia C). Development of a single form of rebalancing therapy for hemophilias A to C is attractive because it makes patient management less complex.
This issue of Blood also has an investigation by de Maat et al to iterate a more potent C1 inhibitor (C1INH) analog.2,5 C1INH accounts for ∼92% of the plasma inhibitory activity against FXIIa and related proteases’ inhibition and ∼48% of the inhibitory activity against PKa (see figure panel C). C1INH is not a potent PKa inhibitor. Fourfold molar excess of plasma C1INH to formed PKa is unable to eliminate the enzyme’s activity. The disorder of acute attacks of HAE occurs in patients with 40% to 60% normal C1INH. In vivo, C1INH probably has a role to balance physiologic BK production. C1INH regulates the constitutive levels of BK, but does not abolish its production. In the recent clinical studies with lanadelumab, a monoclonal antibody to plasma PK, only a 50% decrease in PK levels was sufficient to reduce the incidence of acute attacks of HAE.13
de Maat et al developed a C1INH analog also using α1AT-Pitt as a template. These investigators kept the Arg358 for a reactive center to coagulation proteases. Two forms of α1AT-Pitt were iterated: Ser-Met-Thr-Arg-Ser and Ser-Leu-Leu-Arg-Ser for the P4, P3, P2, P1, and P1′ positions, respectively (see figure panel A).2 Both forms are better PKa and FXIIa inhibitors than C1INH. However, they have reduced but still present specificity to thrombin (IIa), FXa, plasmin, activated protein C, and FXIa. When the P1′ Ser is mutated to Val, the target specificity to IIa, FXa, activated protein C, and plasmin is lost (see figure panel A).2 α1AT-SMTR/V is a slightly better FXIIa inhibitor, and α1AT-SLLR/V is a better PKa inhibitor. Both retain their ability to also inhibit FXIa. These investigators show that α1AT-SMTR/V and α1AT-SLLR/V are more potent inhibitors of contact activation, PKa cleavage of H-kininogen, and BK formation than C1INH (see figure panel C). Furthermore, in a series of murine models that examine the roles of FXIIa, PKa, and BK formation in contact activation, α1AT-SMTR/V and α1AT-SLLR/V block murine models of ferric chloride–induced carotid artery thrombosis, rodent paw swelling, and dextran-induced colitis.
Developing potent inhibitors to contact activation to control BK formation and factor XI activation is important for better management of HAE and may prove useful to inhibit thrombosis on artificial medical surfaces. Is too much inhibition of contact activation and BK formation potentially deleterious? Kgn1−/− mice exist without BK and obvious consequence. The clinical use of α1AT-SMTR/V and α1AT-SLLR/V inhibitors may induce the mild medical hemophilia C (FXIa inhibition), a mild bleeding disorder. This activity may be useful for contact activation-induced thrombosis prevention.
The 2 articles highlighted here show the novelty and diversity of therapeutic development in the areas of hemostasis and contact activation. It is exciting to observe how simple amino acid substitutions make a serpin elastase inhibitor (α1AT) into a potent antithrombin, activated protein C inhibitor, or anti-PKa/FXIIa inhibitor.2,4,11 It is important to learn that downregulation of PN-1 alone improves thrombin generation.
Conflict-of-interest disclosure: A.H.S. declares no competing financial interests.