To the editor:
The high motility of immune cells and their ability to establish cell-to-cell contacts depend on a tight regulation of actin cytoskeleton dynamics. Murine studies have identified the Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome protein (WASP)-interacting protein (WIP) as a key regulator of actin dynamics in immune cells.1-7 Correspondingly, a previously identified WIP-deficient patient suffered from lymphopenia and harbored defects in T-cell proliferation, chemotaxis, and natural killer–mediated cytotoxicity.8
We investigated a 2-year-old patient, who had bronchiolitis and viral pneumonia in his first month of life. At 3 months, he developed pneumonitis requiring mechanical ventilation. Cytomegalovirus (CMV) was detected in all tested body fluids. Intermittent episodes of bloody diarrhea suggestive of inflammatory bowel disease or recurrent intussusception required platelet and red blood cell transfusions. The patient exhibited psychomotor delay without evidence of encephalitis. He had hypergammaglobulinemia and a reduced proportion of memory B cells (supplemental Table 1; supplemental Figure 1, available on the Blood Web site). Profound CD4+ T-cell lymphopenia was associated with skewing toward an effector memory phenotype. Relative proportions of blood TCRγδ+ and CD8+ T cells were increased (supplemental Figure 1), most CD8+ T cells also displaying an exhausted effector memory phenotype. In line with the lack of naïve T cells, thymic development appeared abnormal as supported by thymus involution and low T-cell receptor excision circles and thymic emigrants. T-cell proliferative responses were reduced to borderline normal (supplemental Table 1). As the clinical situation of the patient was deemed too severe for a fully conditioned allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) as performed recently for WIP-deficient patients,9 sequential infusions of peripheral lymphocytes and stem cells from the HLA-identical mother were performed at the 10th to 13th month of life (Figure 1A), resulting in sustained T-cell engraftment, CMV elimination from peripheral blood, and severe infection cessation until the last follow-up at 2 years of age. Applying a next-generation sequencing (NGS)-panel covering >250 causative primary immunodeficiency genes,10,11 we identified a homozygous stop-gain mutation in the WIPF1 gene (c.C373T, p.R125X; Figure 1B), resulting in loss of WIP and WASP expression (Figure 1C), supporting a role for WIP in stabilizing WASP.2
Given the rarity of this disease, we aimed to further explore actin dynamics and ultrastructure in human WIP-deficient leukocytes to provide insight into molecular pathomechanisms. WIP-deficient T cells displayed severely impaired migration toward CCL19 and CXCL12 (Figure 1D). Although the migration defect toward CCL19 might in part result from reduced CCR7 expression (supplemental Figure 2), the defect toward CXCL12 was independent of reduced CXCR4 expression, suggesting an intrinsic defect. We further investigated whether actin polarization abnormalities may underlie impaired migration of WIP-deficient T cells. On poly-l-lysine, patient T cells appeared abnormally large, harbored aberrant shapes, and reduced roundness (Figure 1E-F). Upon chemokine stimulation, these cells emitted multiple actin-rich structures, but failed to elongate and to assemble distinct leading and trailing edges (Figure 1E-F). The morphological abnormalities of WIP-deficient T cells were further confirmed by examining side-by-side T cells from patient and donor origin in a blood sample recovered post-DLI. Indeed, residual WIP-negative patient T cells displayed aberrant morphology and reduced ability to elongate (Figure 1G-H).
To assess the role of WIP in B-cell chemotaxis and to verify that the migration defects were a direct consequence of WIP deficiency, we established 2 complementary cellular models. First, WIP expression was knocked down in normal Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)–immortalized B cells (WIP-KD), leading to concomitant loss of WASP expression (supplemental Figure 3A). Second, a tagged WIP construct was stably introduced in patient EBV–immortalized B cells, restoring WIP expression (supplemental Figure 3A). When exposed to a CCL19 gradient in dedicated chambers,12 WIP-KD cells failed to migrate toward CCL19, as depicted on the tracking maps (supplemental Figure 3B). Accordingly, patient cells failed to migrate toward CCL19, whereas restoration of WIP expression rescued directional migration. Further analysis of cell motility parameters in both models revealed WIP as key regulator of both speed and orientation along the chemokine gradient (Figure 1I). We then studied how WIP deficiency might affect the universal coupling between cell speed and cell persistence. This rule states that fast cells are more directional, because speed promotes actin-dependent maintenance of polarity.13 We first established that this rule applies to normal B cells exposed to a chemokine gradient, as indicated by the positive correlation between speed and forward migration index (Figure 1J). The slope of this correlation was clearly affected in WIP-KD B cells, indicating that increased speed poorly translated into a gain in directionality and suggesting that WIP controls cell polarity. Indeed, following introduction of LifeAct-GFP in WIP-KD B cells, these cells failed to stabilize a polarized morphology (Figure 1K). The cells emitted large filopodia and pseudopodia in various directions, resulting in abnormally high shape volatility. Consequently, WIP-KD B cells failed to orientate toward CCL19 (Figure 1L) and to polarize actin directionally (Figure 1M). Our study highlights the requirement for WIP in sustaining persistent actin-dependent lymphocyte polarity required for chemokine-evoked directional motility.
Although WIP controls natural killer cell–mediated cytotoxicity via a role in lytic granule polarization,8,14 its contribution to CD8+ T-cell–mediated cytotoxicity is unknown. Expanded patient CD8+ T cells expressed normal perforin level (Figure 2A), but displayed reduced surface exposure of LAMP1 upon interaction with αCD3-coated P815 cells (Figure 2B). This defective exocytosis translated into reduced target cell killing (Figure 2C). Prolonged interaction with target cells, used to mimic physiological conditions,15 amplified the killing defect. The reduced capacity of WIP-deficient CD8+ T cells to secrete lytic granules and eliminate target cells may result from a failure to assemble the immunological synapse (IS), a structure that highly depends on actin cytoskeleton dynamics.16 WIP-deficient CD8+ T cells displayed aberrantly elongated shapes and actin-rich protrusions, both when encountering uncoated and αCD3-coated P815 cells (Figure 2D). In contrast to control cells, WIP-deficient CD8+ T cells failed to assemble an IS and to polarize lytic granules toward target cells (Figure 2E-F). In healthy T cells, WIP and F-actin colocalized at the IS, supporting a role of WIP in actin cytoskeleton remodeling during IS assembly, in addition to its role in lytic granule polarization (Figure 2D). Because the sequential unconditioned DLI/HSCT approach resulted in T-cell chimerism only, we wondered whether the IS between WIP-deficient DCs and normal donor T cells would be affected. Indeed, the DC cytoskeleton has been shown to contribute to T-cell capture17 and stability of IS.18 DCs harboring a normal phenotype were differentiated from patient monocytes (data not shown). When coated with superantigens, these cells were able to both capture multiple WIP-positive donor T cells and promote tight contacts (Figure 2G-H), suggesting that the DLI/HSCT procedure normalized IS formation. However, it remains possible that the quality of T-cell activation is impacted by lack of WIP in DCs, calling for cautious follow-up of the patient’s ability to mount T-cell responses. To investigate how WIP may control actin cytoskeleton meshwork organization in the context of the IS, we used structured illumination microscopy to image T cells spreading over ICAM-1/αCD3. As expected, control T cells assembled a wide radial structure, the periphery of which was composed of an F-actin ring, consisting of a dense meshwork of short actin fibers (Figure 2I), with WIP forming tiny patches at the IS periphery intermingling with actin filaments. By contrast, WIP-deficient T cells displayed aberrant morphologies, both over ICAM-1/αCD3 (Figure 2I) and poly-l-lysine (supplemental Figure 4A). Zoomed areas of the T cells from the patient revealed aberrant actin organization dominated by elongated filamentous structures. Analysis of actin coherency showed that WIP-deficient T cells were enriched in actin structures oriented in 1 main direction (Figure 2J; supplemental Figure 4B). These data reveal that WIP controls the organization of a reticulated actin meshwork ultrastructure, contributing to the integrity of the cell cortex and sustaining synaptic lamellipodia assembly.
Collectively, we identify WIP as a central protein to control actin meshwork ultrastructure and dynamics required to maintain lymphocyte shape integrity and to assemble lamellipodial protrusions critical for chemotaxis and lytic synapse formation. The severe clinical course of the WIP-deficient patient and the associated lymphocyte defects illustrate the essential role of WIP for human immunity.
The online version of this article contains a data supplement.
Acknowledgments: The authors are grateful to Gareth Jones for the mCherry-WIP encoding lentiviral construct and thank Marion Gröger and Sabine Rauscher from the Core Facility Imaging of the Medical University of Vienna and Andreas Spittler from the Core Facility Flow Cytometry of the Medical University of Vienna. The authors thank Sophie Allart for technical assistance at the Cellular Imaging Facility of TRI-CPTP (Toulouse, France) and Frédérique Gaits-Iacovoni from the Cellular Imaging Facility of TRI-I2MC (Toulouse, France). The authors are grateful to Delphine Guipouy from CPTP (Toulouse, France) and Cecilia Domínguez Conde, Rico Chandra Ardy, and Raúl Jiménez Heredia from LBI-RUD (Vienna, Austria) for technical advice and discussion.
This work was supported in part by the Styrian Children’s Cancer Aid Fund (Steirische Kinderkrebshilfe) (M.G.S.) and by the Vienna Science and Technology Fund (WWTF-LS16-060) (K.B. and L.D.), the MINECO/FEDER (SAF2015-70368-R) (I.M.A.), and the French National Agency for Research (ANR-13-BSV1-0031) (L.D.).
Contribution: L.P., M.G.S., K.B., and L.D. designed the study; L.P., M.G.S., R.H., T.H., E.S., and L.D. collected data; L.P., M.G.S., R.H., J.R.-B., T.H., E.S., I.M.A., K.B., and L.D. analyzed and interpreted data; L.P. performed statistical analysis; C.U., W.S., and M.G.S. cared for the patient; L.P., K.B., and L.D. wrote the manuscript with input from M.G.S.; and all authors approved the final version of the manuscript.
Conflict-of-interest disclosure: The authors declare no competing financial interests.
Correspondence: Loïc Dupré, INSERM UMR1043, Centre de Physiopathologie de Toulouse Purpan, CHU Purpan, 1, Place du Dr Baylac, 31300 Toulouse, France; e-mail: email@example.com; and Kaan Boztug, Ludwig Boltzmann. Institute for Rare and Undiagnosed Diseases, Lazarettgasse 14 AKH BT 25.3, A-1090 Vienna, Austria; e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org.
L.P. and M.G.S. contributed equally to this study.
K.B. and L.D. contributed equally to this study.