To test the hypothesis that platelet activation contributes to tumor dissemination, we studied metastasis in mice lacking Gαq, a G protein critical for platelet activation. Loss of platelet activation resulted in a profound diminution in both experimental and spontaneous metastases. Analyses of the distribution of radiolabeled tumor cells demonstrated that platelet function, like fibrinogen, significantly improved the survival of circulating tumor cells in the pulmonary vasculature. More detailed studies showed that the increase in metastatic success conferred by either platelets or fibrinogen was linked to natural killer cell function. Specifically, the pronounced reduction in tumor cell survival observed in fibrinogen- and Gαq-deficient mice relative to control animals was eliminated by the immunologic or genetic depletion of natural killer cells. These studies establish an important link between hemostatic factors and innate immunity and indicate that one mechanism by which the platelet-fibrin(ogen) axis contributes to metastatic potential is by impeding natural killer cell elimination of tumor cells.
A persuasive body of evidence has accumulated associating hemostatic factors with tumor growth, stroma formation, and tumor dissemination.1-3 Clinical studies have shown that expression of procoagulants by cancer cells is prognostic of poor outcome.4-6 Furthermore, the expression of tissue factor by tumor cells has been shown to promote metastatic disease in experimental animals,7 whereas inhibitors of thrombin and other coagulation factors diminished metastatic potential.1,8 The available data support the general hypothesis that local thrombin generation enhances tumor dissemination. However, it is presently not clear which specific thrombin substrates are important mediators of the metastatic process. Recent studies revealed that fibrinogen deficiency significantly diminishes metastatic potential, suggesting that fibrinogen is at least one thrombin substrate important in metastasis.9,10 However, it is likely that other thrombin substrates also contribute to tumor cell metastasis based on the finding that pharmacologic inhibition of thrombin resulted in decreased metastatic potential even in the absence of fibrinogen.10
Several studies support the view that thrombin-mediated platelet activation may play a role in tumor biology. The elimination of circulating platelets with antiplatelet antibodies was shown to result in a significant diminution in metastases using several transplantable murine tumor models.11,12 Competitive inhibition of the key platelet integrin, αIIbβ3, either pharmacologically or with antibodies to β3, also diminished metastatic potential.13,14 Similarly, pharmacologic inhibitors of platelet activation have been shown to decrease the metastatic potential of circulating tumor cells.15,16 More recently, the genetic loss of the integrin β3 subunit in mice was shown to diminish metastasis.17
Platelets could influence metastatic potential via several mechanisms. Platelet granules contain a variety of cellular growth factors (eg, platelet-derived growth factor [PDGF], vascular endothelial growth factor [VEGF]), matrix proteins (eg, vitronectin, fibronectin), and inflammatory mediators (eg, platelet factor-4, interleukin-8, macrophage inflammatory protein 1α [MIP-1α], RANTES [regulated on activation, normal T expressed, and secreted], CCL17, CCXL1, CXCL5) that might influence tumor cell behavior and stroma formation.18-20 Platelets may also contribute to the physical interaction between circulating tumor cells and vascular endothelial cells by supporting the stable adhesion to endothelium and/or transmigration of tumor cells out of the vasculature. Local platelet activation could promote the migration of inflammatory cells, enhancing tumor stroma formation. Alternatively, tumor cell–associated platelets could facilitate tumor cell metastasis by preventing interactions between tumor cells and innate immune cells. This latter concept has been suggested by immunodepletion studies in vivo and studies showing that platelets can limit the ability of natural killer (NK) cells to lyse tumor cells in vitro.21 This finding is consistent with the fact that NK cell–mediated elimination of target cells requires direct cell-cell contact. Despite substantial data pointing to a role for the fibrinogen-platelet axis in tumor progression, a mechanistic understanding of the interplay between hemostatic system components and tumor progression has remained elusive.
The recent development of gene-targeted mice with qualitative and quantitative platelet defects (eg, Gαq-, nuclear factor–erythroid 2 [NF-E2]–, and protease-activated receptor 4 [PAR-4]–deficient mice) has provided an opportunity to better define the role of platelets in disease processes.22-24 In order to examine the role of platelets in tumor growth and dissemination, we focused on mice lacking Gαq, a G protein critical for platelet activation. Gαq–/–mice have normal platelet numbers, thus retaining normal rheology within the circulation. However, Gαq-deficient platelets do not respond in vitro to physiologically relevant agonists, including adenosine diphosphate (ADP), thrombin, collagen, and thromboxane.23 We report that metastatic potential is dramatically diminished in mice with defective platelet activation, and the platelet-fibrin(ogen) axis supports tumor cell dissemination via a mechanism related to natural killer cell function.
Material and methods
Gαq- and fibrinogen-deficient mice have been previously described.23,25 Transgenic mice expressing an Ly49A cDNA under the control of a granzyme A promoter resulting in a severe defect in natural killer cells were described by Kim et al26 (here referred to as NK– mice). Genotyping of fibrinogen-deficient and NK– mice was accomplished as previously described.25,26 Gαq-deficient mice were genotyped by a multiplex polymerase chain reaction (PCR) strategy using 3 primers. The wild-type Gαq allele was detected using primer 1 (5′TTC CCAAGA TAG CAC CAC CAA CCG AG3′) and primer 2 (5′CCAACA GCA TTT CAA CAA CAA GAG GCA C 3′) yielding a 385–base pair (bp) PCR product. The mutant Gαq allele was detected with primer 2 (see above) and primer 3 (5′GAT TCG CAG CGC ATC GCC TTC TAT3′) yielding a 264-bp PCR product. Fibrinogen-deficient and NK– mice were inbred into the C57Bl/6 background for 7 generations. Gαq-deficient mice were inbred into the C57Bl/6 background for 4 generations. Age- and sex-matched cohorts of wild-type (Gαq+/+) and Gαq-deficient (Gα–/–) animals were enrolled in all experiments. Studies of fibrinogen-deficient (Fib–/–) mice were done with cohorts of age- and sex-matched Fib+/– controls. The study protocols were approved by the Cincinnati Children's Hospital Research Foundation Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee in accordance with the guidelines of the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
Carotid artery thrombosis
Thrombus formation in the carotid artery of anesthetized mice was induced using FeCl3 as previously described.27 Blood flow through the carotid artery was monitored using a Doppler flow probe (no. 0.5VB307; Transonic Systems, Ithaca, NY) connected to a flow meter (T106; Transonic Systems), and thrombus formation was recorded continuously for up to 30 minutes using a miniature video camera (ProVideo CVC-514; CSI/SPECO, Amityville, NY). After the 30-minute recording period, anesthetized animals were perfused with 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) and the injured carotid arteries were collected for analysis under a Hitachi S350 electron microscope (Hitachi, Tokyo, Japan) and under an Olympus BX60 microscope equipped with a Plan-Apo 2×/0.08 objective lens (Olympus, Melville, NY).
Tumor cell transplantation and histologic analysis
B16-BL6 melanoma cells and green fluorescent protein–expressing Lewis lung carcinoma (LLCGFP) cells (both C57BL/6-derived tumor cells lines) were grown in vitro and injected into mice as previously described.9,10 For experimental metastasis assays, mice were anesthetized with 2% isoflurane and 300 μL of a single-cell suspension was injected into the lateral tail vein. Lung tissue was collected 14 days after injection of LLCGFP cells and 17 days after injection of B16-BL6 cells for quantitative analysis of metastatic foci. In studies of primary tumor growth and spontaneous metastasis, mice were anesthetized and 80 μL of single-cell suspension was injected intradermally into the dorsal skin. Primary tumor growth was followed by serial calipation.28 Tumor tissues were fixed in 10% neutral-buffered formalin and processed for microscopic analysis as previously described.9,10
Bone marrow transplantation
Wild-type C57Bl/6 recipient mice were conditioned with 1175 cGy delivered in 2 doses of 700 cGy and 475 cGy at a rate of 63 cGy/minute administered 3 hours apart using a cesium-source gamma-irradiator (Mark 1-68 cesium irradiator; J. L. Shepherd, San Fernando, CA).29 Donor Gαq+/+ and Gαq–/– mice inbred into the C57Bl/6 background for 4 generations were killed and the pelvis, femora, and tibiae were sterilely harvested. Bone marrow was flushed from the bones with PBS and passed through a 40-μm mesh cell strainer. Mononuclear cells were separated by centrifugation in a Ficoll gradient. Irradiated recipient mice were intravenously injected with approximately 4 × 106 mononuclear bone marrow cells in 300 μL of PBS. Mice were enrolled in cancer studies 8 weeks after transplantation.
Spontaneous metastasis assays
LLCGFP cells were transplanted into the dorsal subcutis overlying the lumbosacral spine as previously described.9 Twelve days later, the mice were anesthetized and the head, chest, and upper abdomen were shielded with 6 cm of SuperFlab (Radiation Products Design, Albertville, MN) as previously described.9 The tumors were then irradiated with 6 000 cGy using an electron beam irradiator (Siemens Mevatron, Munich, Germany). The mice were harvested 14 days later and organs were harvested for assessment.
Fate of tumor cells labeled with [125I]-iododeoxyuridine
LLCGFP cells were radiolabeled with 5-[125I]iodo-2′-deoxyuridine (MP Biomedical, Irvine, CA) essentially as previously described.10 Either 3 × 105 (Gαq-deficient mice) or 8 × 104 (fibrinogen-deficient mice) radiolabeled cells were injected intravenously. Organs were harvested at specified times points and washed for 3 days in 70% ethanol to remove free isotope. Radioisotope levels in the input inoculums and in each organ were determined with a Cobra gamma counter (Packard, Meridien, CT).
Immunologic elimination of NK cells in vivo and NK cytotoxicity assays
Rabbit antimouse asialo GM1 polyclonal antibody (Cedarlane, Hornby, ON, Canada) was reconstituted per the manufacturer's recommendation. For tumor metastasis studies, mice were pretreated intravenously with either 100 μL anti–asialo GM1 polyclonal antibody or carrier 48 hours prior to inoculation with tumor cells. The mice received a second dose of antibody/carrier on the day of tumor cell injection. For splenic NK assays, mice were intravenously injected with 100 μL anti–asialo GM1 polyclonal antibody 48 hours prior to harvesting spleens. Twenty-four hours prior to being killed, mice were given an intraperitoneal injection of 150 μg poly I:C (Sigma-Aldrich, St Louis, MO). At the time they were killed, the mice were perfused with 5 mL of PBS via intracardiac infusion prior to harvesting spleens. Mononuclear splenocytes were separated by Ficoll gradient centrifugation and used for in vitro 51Cr-release assays using YAC-1 target cells essentially as previously described.30
In vivo thrombus formation is severely compromised in Gαq-deficient mice
As a prelude to detailed studies of tumor progression, we explored whether Gαq deficiency23 resulted in a major defect in platelet thrombus formation in vivo. Thrombus formation within FeCl3-injured carotid arteries was compared in control and Gαq-deficient mice using intravital videomicroscopy.27 In Gαq+/+ mice (n = 4), visible thrombus formation was evident immediately after the FeCl3 challenge and resulted in occlusion of the carotid artery within 10.1 ± 0.9 minutes after FeCl3 application. In contrast, Gαq–/– animals (n = 5) never developed visible platelet deposition, and blood flow through the carotid artery as measured using a Doppler flow probe remained unchanged for the entire 30-minute observation period (data not shown). Histologic analysis (Figure 1A) and scanning electron microscopic analysis (Figure 1B) of carotid arteries collected 30 minutes after FeCl3 application confirmed the formation of large, dense thrombi in Gαq+/+ mice. The artery walls in Gαq–/– mice, however, exhibited only a modest dusting of platelets (Figure 1) that could only be appreciated using high-magnification scanning electron microscopy (Figure 1B). These platelets appeared to be trapped within the small amounts of fibrin formed on the injured arterial surface, as opposed to being directly adherent to the vessel wall.
Gαq is an important determinant of the metastatic potential of circulating tumor cells
In order to examine the role of platelet activation in metastasis, we compared the formation of pulmonary metastatic foci within immunocompetent control and Gαq-deficient mice following the intravenous injection of either Lewis lung carcinoma cells (LLCGFP cells; Figure 2A,C-D) or B16-BL6 melanoma cells (Figure 2B,E-F). Regardless of the tumor line employed, the number of lung metastases in Gαq–/– mice was 2 orders-of-magnitude less than that observed in control animals. Similar results were obtained in 3 independent experiments. While the number of metastases was strongly dependent on Gαq genotype, the size and overall appearance of individual pulmonary foci were similar in Gαq+/+ and Gαq–/– mice. A microscopic analysis of lung tissues from control and Gαq–/– mice also did not reveal any difference in the qualitative features of individual metastatic lesions within these experimental animals (data not shown).
In order to establish that the diminution in metastases observed in Gαq–/– mice was due to the absence of Gαq within cells of hematopoietic origin, we limited the genetic deficit in Gαq to hematopoietic cells by bone marrow transplantation. Bone marrow mononuclear cells harvested separately from Gαq+/+ and Gαq–/– mice were injected into lethally irradiated, wild-type C57Bl/6 mice. After a recovery period of 8 weeks to ensure the reconstitution of all blood cell lines, these mice were intravenously injected with LLCGFP cells. Complete blood counts performed prior to tumor cell injection on 3 randomly selected mice of each genotype demonstrated no Gαq-dependent differences in white blood cell, red blood cell, or platelet reconstitution (data not shown). Similar to findings in mice with a constitutional deficit in Gαq, mice that received transplants of bone marrow from Gαq-deficient donors developed far fewer pulmonary metastases than mice that received transplants of bone marrow from wild-type donors (Figure 3). To establish the full recovery of hematopoiesis in transplant recipients used in tumor studies, cohorts of 4 randomly chosen tumor-bearing mice of each genotype were evaluated with complete blood counts at the time that they were killed. No significant difference was observed in any hematologic parameter, including white blood cell counts (Gαq+/+ 3.7 ± 0.47 × 109/L; Gαq–/– 3.54 ± 0.54 × 109/L), hemoglobin concentration (Gαq+/+ 112 ± 10.0 g/L; Gαq–/– 113 ± 8.0 g/L), and platelet counts (Gαq+/+ 699 ± 64 × 109/L; Gαq–/– 625 ± 80 × 109/L; n = 4 for each genotype; P value not significant for each comparison using Mann-Whitney U test). Furthermore, these values were not significantly different from the hematologic parameters of wild-type and Gαq–/– mice that had not undergone the bone marrow transplantation procedure (data not shown). Microscopic analyses of blood smears also showed no differences in white cell subpopulations or red cell and platelet morphology. PCR analysis of both whole blood and bone marrow DNA demonstrated that at least 99% of the bone marrow cells were donor derived (data not shown). Bone marrow transplantation in itself was not a determinant of metastatic potential; no difference in pulmonary metastatic load was observed between nonirradiated wild-type mice and wild-type mice that received transplants of wild-type bone marrow (Figure 3). These data imply that Gαq-mediated signaling within hematopoietic cells is the dominant factor determining metastatic potential in Gαq-sufficient animals.
Gαq-mediated platelet activation promotes spontaneous metastasis but does not affect established tumor growth
In order to explore the role of platelet activation in primary tumor growth, LLCGFP cells were transplanted into the dorsal subcutis of Gαq–/– and Gαq+/+ mice. Palpable tumors were present in mice of both genotypes within 4 days of inoculation. No genotype-dependent differences in tumor growth rate were observed based on serial calipation of tumor size28 over a 12-day observation period (Figure 4A). Tumor weight measured at the time that the animal was killed was not influenced by Gαq deficiency. Gαq+/+ mice had a median tumor mass of 387 mg (range, 60-785 mg; n = 9) compared with a median of 406 mg in Gαq–/– mice (range, 250-911 mg; n = 8; P > .6, Mann-Whitney U Test). Microscopic analysis of tissue sections prepared from LLCGFP tumors did not reveal any genotype-dependent differences (Figure 4C-D). LLCGFP tumors grew as dense masses of highly vascularized anaplastic cells with numerous mitoses. Small, focal areas of necrosis and numerous small blood vessels were evident in tumors from mice of both genotypes.
The fact that subcutaneous primary tumor growth was indistinguishable in control and Gαq–/– mice permitted a meaningful analysis of the platelet activation defect on spontaneous metastasis. To do this, we transplanted LLCGFP cells into the dorsal subcutis overlying the lumbosacral spine. This caudal location was chosen so the primary tumor could later be eliminated by local radiotherapy.9 Consistent with previous results, tumors grew similarly in Gαq+/+ and Gαq–/– mice reaching approximately 300 mm3 within 12 days. Radiotherapy (6000 cGy) was used to control the primary tumor in order to avoid the bleeding risk associated with surgical resection. During radiotherapy, the lungs and abdomen were shielded to minimize any general toxicity and to ensure the continued viability of any tumor cells within the lung.9 Two weeks after elimination of the primary tumor, the mice were killed and metastatic foci on the lungs, liver, spleen, and kidneys enumerated. Like the experimental metastasis analyses, Gαq deficiency resulted in a significant decrease in spontaneous pulmonary metastases (Figure 4B). Spontaneous liver metastases also were less frequent in Gαq–/– mice relative to controls, but they were too few in number to make meaningful comparisons. Therefore, platelet activation appears to be a strong determinant of the more complex process of spontaneous metastasis.
Platelets enhance the survival of embolic tumor cells via a mechanism linked to natural killer cells
In order to examine the fate of circulating tumor cells in mice lacking platelet function, [125I]-iododeoxyuridine–labeled LLCGFP 8,10 cells were intravenously injected into 3 cohorts of Gαq+/+ and Gαq–/– mice. Individual cohorts were killed 20 minutes, 5 hours, and 24 hours after tumor cell inoculation and the relative distribution of radiolabel in blood and organs was measured. Consistent with previous reports,8,10 a significant fraction of tumor cells rapidly became localized within the lungs of control animals. Approximately half of the injected tumor cells were found in the lungs within 20 minutes of injection (Figure 5A). The residual tumor cells were widely dispersed with small numbers in blood (< 5%), liver (< 10%), spleen (< 1%), and other tissues. Also consistent with previous reports, a time-dependent process of tumor cell elimination was evident within the lungs of control mice, with only 10% of the inoculum remaining at 24 hours. The initial localization of tumor cells within the lungs (Figure 5A) and other tissues (data not shown) was not significantly different between Gαq+/+ and Gαq–/– mice. However, consistent with their reduced risk of forming advanced pulmonary metastases, the loss of tumor cells within the lung was far more precipitous in Gαq–/– mice than in control animals. Only approximately 1% of the tumor cell inoculum remained within the lungs of Gαq–/– mice 24 hours after injection (Figure 5A). This same pattern of precipitous tumor cell elimination was observed previously in mice either lacking fibrinogen or treated with thrombin inhibitor,8,10 suggesting a mechanistic linkage between platelet activation and fibrin(ogen) in circulating tumor cell survival.
One potential mechanism by which platelet-fibrin(ogen) microthrombi might support the metastatic success of embolic tumor cells is by forming a physical barrier that partially protects the malignant cells from natural killer (NK) cell–mediated elimination within the pulmonary vasculature.21 In order to test this theory, comparative studies of tumor cell survival in vivo were done in control and Gαq–/– mice in which NK cells were depleted using anti–asialo GM1 polyclonal antibodies.31 As expected, control studies showed the successful immunodepletion of NK cells by this established method; splenic effector cells collected from wild-type mice treated with anti–asialo GM1 displayed no natural killer function in vitro using standard 51Cr-release assay with YAC-1 target cells (Figure 5B). An additional control study showed that the loss of Gαq did not result in any inherent loss of NK function; splenic NK cells prepared from wild-type and Gαq-deficient mice were equally effective in killing YAC-1 target cells in vitro at all target-to–effector cell ratios tested (data not shown). Nevertheless, the large difference in tumor cell survival observed within the lungs of control and Gαq–/– mice in vivo was found to be dependent on NK cell function in tumor cell fate studies. Here, 125I-labeled LLCGFP cells were injected into the circulation of cohorts of wild-type and Gαq–/– mice with and without NK cell immunodepletion and the residual tumor cells present within lung tissue were established 24 hours later using a gamma counter. Consistent with our earlier observations, in cohorts of carrier-treated mice (ie, no antibody), the number of residual pulmonary tumor cells was distinctly diminished in Gαq–/– mice relative to wild-type animals (Figure 5C). Furthermore, consistent with the known NK sensitivity of LLC tumor cells in metastasis assays, pretreatment with anti–asialo GM1 antibodies resulted in a significant increase in the number of tumor cells in the lungs of wild-type mice at 24 hours (compare Figure 5C with 5D). However, a far more revealing finding was that while Gαq was clearly an important determinant of tumor cell survival in NK-sufficient mice, Gαq was no longer a determinant of tumor cell success in the context of NK cell depletion (Figure 5D). This experiment was repeated twice with similar results.
Fibrinogen supports the survival of embolic tumor cells via a mechanism linked to natural killer cells
In order to determine if the role of fibrin(ogen) in metastasis is also mechanistically linked to natural killer cell function, we took advantage of established transgenic mice shown to lack NK cells as a consequence of the inappropriate expression of Ly49A (kindly provided by Wayne Yokoyama, Washington University, St Louis, MO).26 These mice (referred to here as NK–) have a specific defect in NK cell function.26 NK– mice were crossed with fibrinogen-deficient mice in order to generate animals with single and combined deficits in fibrinogen and natural killer cells. Mice of the following 4 genotypes were challenged with an intravenous injection of LLCGFP cells: Fib+/NK+, Fib–/NK+, Fib+/NK–, Fib–/NK–. Consistent with earlier reports,26 the loss of NK function in NK– mice resulted in a major increase (> 20-fold) in the number of metastatic pulmonary foci that developed over a 2-week period relative to control animals (data not shown). In order to avoid a situation where NK– mice would have more metastatic foci than could reasonably be enumerated, cohorts of NK+ mice were injected with 4 × 105 LLCGFP cells, whereas cohorts of NK– animals were injected with 8 × 104 cells obtained from the same cell suspension. The mice were killed 14 days later and pulmonary metastatic foci counted. In mice with intact NK function, the genetic elimination of fibrinogen resulted in a significant decrease in pulmonary metastasis (Figure 6A), consistent with previous results.10 However, in mice lacking functional NK cells, fibrinogen deficiency was no longer a significant determinant of metastatic potential (Figure 6B). This experiment was performed 3 times with similar results.
To examine the interplay between fibrin(ogen) and NK cells in defining the early survival of circulating tumor cells, we examined tumor cell fate following the injection of 8 × 104125I-labeled LLCGFP cells into mice with single and combined genetic deficits in fibrinogen and NK cells. The mice were killed 24 hours after tumor cell injection and radiolabel in lungs and other tissues measured. Similar to our observations in Gαq-deficient mice and previously published results,10 Fib–/– mice with intact NK function exhibited a more precipitous elimination of pulmonary tumor cells relative to fibrinogen-sufficient mice (Figure 6A). Predictably, the level of residual pulmonary tumor cells was significantly higher in NK– mice relative to mice retaining NK function (compare Figure 6A with 6B). More importantly, in mice lacking NK cells, fibrinogen was no longer a significant determinant of early tumor cell survival within the lungs (Figure 6B). Thus, the diminution in metastatic lesions observed in the absence of either platelet activation or fibrinogen appears to result in part from differences in NK-mediated tumor cell elimination early after arrival in the circulation.
We demonstrate that both platelet activation and fibrin(ogen) increase the metastatic success of embolic tumor cells. Given that fibrinogen is actively engaged by activated platelets, these factors probably act in concert in altering tumor cell metastatic potential. Nevertheless, neither platelet activation (this report) nor fibrin(ogen)9 is essential for the growth of established tumors. Rather, tumor cell fate analyses showed that platelet activation, like fibrinogen,10 enhances the early survival of embolic tumor cells within the pulmonary vasculature. Furthermore, our studies demonstrate that at least one mechanism by which hemostatic factors support metastasis in vivo is by impeding tumor cell clearance by natural killer cells.
The loss of Gαq results in a severe defect in platelet activation in vitro23 and here we extended this observation to show that platelet thrombus formation is profoundly impaired in Gαq–/– mice in vivo. This defect also confers a dramatic decrease in the metastatic potential of tumor cells in both experimental and spontaneous metastasis assays. The finding that metastatic potential is similarly diminished in cohorts of mice constitutionally deficient in Gαq and cohorts of mice in which the loss of Gαq was restricted to hematopoietic cells (through bone marrow transplantation) further supports the notion that cells of hematopoietic origin constitute the predominant determinant of metastatic success in Gαq–/– mice. Platelet function appears to be central to metastatic potential (see “Discussion”), but a lingering question is whether the loss of Gαq in leukocytes also contributes to the diminution in experimental metastasis. While a contribution of leukocytes has not been formally excluded, loss of Gαq does not result in quantitative defects in leukocytes or the ability of hematopoietic stem cells to reconstitute bone marrow. Furthermore, we have found that the inherent capacity of NK cells to kill target cells in vitro is comparable using effector cells prepared from control and Gαq–/– mice. The current working view that the loss of platelet function constitutes the major determinant of metastasis in Gαq-deficient mice is consistent with earlier reports showing that pharmacologic or immunologic agents capable of diminishing platelet function markedly reduce metastasis.11,12,32,33 This conclusion is further supported by recent reports of dramatically reduced metastatic potential in mice with either a quantitative platelet defect (eg, NF-E2–deficient mice) or a defect in thrombin-mediated platelet activation (eg, PAR-4–deficient mice).34 Finally, mice lacking either fibrinogen or platelet fibrinogen receptor αIIbβ3 also exhibit reduced metastatic potential.17 Taken together, the low metastatic potential observed in Gαq–/– mice is likely to be largely, if not solely, a consequence of the profound defect in platelet function.
Platelets and fibrin(ogen) could influence tumor biology through several possible mechanisms. Given the varied challenges confronting metastatic tumor cells, including transendothelial cell migration, safe transit within the circulation, stabilization within distant vascular beds, growth, and the establishment of a supportive vasculature, local platelet activation might offer some significant advantages at certain steps of this process and be a significant liability at other steps. Potential benefits include the following: (i) the local release of platelet-derived growth factors and other effectors (eg, inflammatory mediators) could promote tumor cell growth and stroma formation18,20 ; (ii) local platelet-fibrin deposition could sustain tumor cell immobilization within the circulation and provide a supportive matrix for cell proliferation; and (iii) platelets associated with embolic tumor cells could limit anti–tumor cell immune surveillance mechanisms. On the other hand, possible deleterious consequences of tumor-associated platelet-fibrin deposition include impeding local nutrient delivery and gas exchange or restricting tumor cell migration. It follows that any setting where persistent platelet thrombi were present within tumor neovasculature would tend to slow tumor growth.35 While platelets may strongly influence tumor growth in specific contexts, the present studies indicate that platelet activation is neither strictly required nor uniformly deleterious for either tumor growth or the establishment of a supportive vasculature. Finally, whatever the benefits and liabilities of platelets for tumor progression, the data presented here show that in the balance, a functional defect in platelet activation strongly diminishes metastatic success.
The available data indicate that neither platelets (these studies) nor fibrin(ogen)10 is important in the initial adhesion/localization of tumor cells within the pulmonary vasculature. Nevertheless, the adhesive properties of activated platelets and fibrin(ogen) may still be of significant importance in this process by supporting the sustained adhesion of tumor cells within high shear stress or turbulent vascular environments. However, perhaps the most intriguing facet of the present study is the finding that the benefits to tumor cell emboli that stem from platelet-fibrin deposition are not limited to the mechanical property of adhesion. Rather, the data presented here indicate that tumor cell–associated platelet-fibrin deposition provides a means for tumor cells to evade NK cell–mediated elimination, a finding that further ties hemostatic factors to immune surveillance. Given that NK-mediated killing requires direct contact with target cells, one attractive theory consistent with the available data is that platelet-fibrin microthrombi act as a physical barrier preventing contact of NK cells with target tumor cells. This general hypothesis is consistent with earlier studies showing that activated platelets can impede NK cell–mediated cell lysis in vitro.21 Under this scenario, the contribution of fibrin(ogen) to tumor cell metastasis might be primarily the stabilization of tumor-associated platelets that effectively stand in the way of NK cell access. However, an alternative model is that NK cells are effectively pacified by immunomodulatory receptor engagement of tumor cell–associated microthrombi. In this regard, it should be noted that NK cells are known to express receptors (eg, αMβ2)36 capable of binding immobilized fibrin(ogen) and platelet surface components. Similarly, the local release of cytokines from platelets associated with embolic tumor cells might regulate NK function. A final model consistent with the finding that Gαq ceases to be a determinant of metastatic potential in the absence of NK cells is that Gαq is a critical regulator of NK function. While still viable, this later hypothesis has the liability that in order to explain the experimental findings, the loss of any Gαq signaling in NK cells would have to markedly improve the ability of NK cells to kill tumor cells. The fact that NK cell lysis of target cells in vitro was not altered by Gαq deficiency would seem to argue against this concept. Furthermore, the parallel nature of our findings with fibrinogen- and Gαq-deficient mice points more toward microthrombus formation as being a central determinant of NK-mediated tumor cell elimination rather than a putative role of Gαq in NK cell function. Since platelets would be restricted to the vascular compartment, we would predict that whatever the interplay between activated platelets and NK cell–mediated tumor cell elimination, the interchange is likely to influence events while the tumor cells are still within the vasculature. While our studies highlight that tumor cells may capitalize on hemostatic system components to evade innate immune surveillance in certain contexts, it is important to emphasize that settings will almost certainly be found where hemostatic factors contribute to tumor biology, regardless of the presence or absence of NK function, such as tumors established within areas prone to recurrent trauma.35
In summary, these studies demonstrate that platelets and fibrin(ogen) enhance metastatic potential in part by impeding intravascular tumor cell clearance by NK cells. These observations are particularly noteworthy in light of clinical observations, suggesting that agents targeting thrombin generation and platelet function can improve outcome for certain types of cancer.37-39 This would suggest that therapies designed to inhibit the association of tumor cells with platelets/fibrin(ogen), in combination with therapeutic strategies that augment the clearance of tumor cells via the innate immune system, could be effective for the treatment of certain malignancies. Agents that target specific signal transduction proteins involved in platelet activation or limit platelet aggregation could be particularly attractive candidates since the remainder of the clotting cascade would be left intact.
Prepublished online as Blood First Edition Paper, September 14, 2004; DOI 10.1182/blood-2004-06-2272.
Supported in part by grants HL074363 (J.S.P.) and HL71555 (J.L.D.) from the National Institutes of Health.
An Inside Blood analysis of this article appears in the front of this issue.
The publication costs of this article were defrayed in part by page charge payment. Therefore, and solely to indicate this fact, this article is hereby marked “advertisement” in accordance with 18 U.S.C. section 1734.
The authors would like to thank Drs Christopher Karp and Jonathan Katz for their many helpful suggestions. We also thank Carol Moore for her expert assistance with the NK cell function assays, as well as Drs Ronald Gordon and Norman Katz (Mount Sinai School of Medicine, NY) for their help with electron microscopy, and Igor Chershnev and Heikki Vaanen (Mount Sinai School of Medicine) for their help with the thrombus model. We gratefully acknowledge Jeffrey Bailey and Victoria Seummey-Harmer for their assistance with the bone marrow transplant protocol and Dr Beth A. Myers for critically reviewing the manuscript.