https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3201-6109
Key Points
CNB accurately diagnoses lymphoma in most instances but increases the risk of erroneous or nondefinitive conclusions.
Systematic expert review highly contributes to a precise lymphoma diagnosis, especially in cases sampled by CNB.
Subjects:
Lymphoid Neoplasia
Abstract
According to expert guidelines, lymph node surgical excision is the standard of care for lymphoma diagnosis. However, core needle biopsy (CNB) has become widely accepted as part of the lymphoma diagnostic workup over the past decades. The aim of this study was to present the largest multicenter inventory of lymph nodes sampled either by CNB or surgical excision in patients with suspected lymphoma and to compare their diagnostic performance in routine pathologic practice. We reviewed 32 285 cases registered in the French Lymphopath network, which provides a systematic expert review of all lymphoma diagnoses in France, and evaluated the percentage of CNB and surgical excision cases accurately diagnosed according to the World Health Organization classification. Although CNB provided a definitive diagnosis in 92.3% and seemed to be a reliable method of investigation for most patients with suspected lymphoma, it remained less conclusive than surgical excision, which provided a definitive diagnosis in 98.1%. Discordance rates between referral and expert diagnoses were higher on CNB (23.1%) than on surgical excision (21.2%; P = .004), and referral pathologists provided more cases with unclassified lymphoma or equivocal lesion through CNB. In such cases, expert review improved the diagnostic workup by classifying ∼90% of cases, with higher efficacy on surgical excision (93.3%) than CNB (81.4%; P < 10−6). Moreover, diagnostic concordance for reactive lesions was higher on surgical excision than CNB (P = .009). Overall, although CNB accurately diagnoses lymphoma in most instances, it increases the risk of erroneous or nondefinitive conclusions. This large-scale survey also emphasizes the need for systematic expert review in cases of lymphoma suspicion, especially in those sampled by using CNB.
Subjects:
Lymphoid Neoplasia
References
1.
Swerdlow
SH
, Campo
E
, Harris
NL
, et al. World Health Organization Classification of Tumours of Haematopoietic and Lymphoid Tissues. 4th ed.. Lyon, France
: IARC Press
; 2008
.2.
Wilkins
BS
. Pitfalls in lymphoma pathology: avoiding errors in diagnosis of lymphoid tissues
. J Clin Pathol
. 2011
;64
(6
):466
-476
.3.
Laurent
C
, Baron
M
, Amara
N
, et al. Impact of expert pathologic review of lymphoma diagnosis: study of patients from the French Lymphopath Network
. J Clin Oncol
. 2017
;35
(18
):2008
-2017
.4.
Swerdlow
SH
, Campo
E
, Harris
NL
, et al. WHO Classification of Tumours of Haematopoietic and Lymphoid Tissues. Lyon, France
: IARC
; 2017
.5.
Eichenauer
DA
, Aleman
BMP
, André
M
, et al. Hodgkin lymphoma: ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up
. Ann Oncol
. 2018
;29
(suppl 4
):iv19
-iv29
.6.
Tilly
H
, Gomes da Silva
M
, Vitolo
U
, et al. ESMO Guidelines Committee. Diffuse large B-cell lymphoma (DLBCL): ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up
. Ann Oncol
. 2015
;26
(suppl 5
):v116
-v125
.7.
d’Amore
F
, Gaulard
P
, Trümper
L
, et al. ESMO Guidelines Committee. Peripheral T-cell lymphomas: ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines for diagnosis, treatment and follow-up
. Ann Oncol
. 2015
;26
(suppl 5
):v108
-v115
.8.
Matasar
MJ
, Shi
W
, Silberstien
J
, et al. Expert second-opinion pathology review of lymphoma in the era of the World Health Organization classification
. Ann Oncol
. 2012
;23
(1
):159
-166
.9.
Higgins
RA
, Blankenship
JE
, Kinney
MC
. Application of immunohistochemistry in the diagnosis of non-Hodgkin and Hodgkin lymphoma
. Arch Pathol Lab Med
. 2008
;132
(3
):441
-461
.10.
Pruneri
G
, Gigli
F
, Rafaniello Raviele
P
, et al. Core needle biopsy as a front line diagnostic approach for lymphoma patients
. Hematol Oncol
. 2015
;33
(4
):247
-249
.11.
Ben-Yehuda
D
, Polliack
A
, Okon
E
, et al. Image-guided core-needle biopsy in malignant lymphoma: experience with 100 patients that suggests the technique is reliable
. J Clin Oncol
. 1996
;14
(9
):2431
-2434
.12.
Demharter
J
, Müller
P
, Wagner
T
, Schlimok
G
, Haude
K
, Bohndorf
K
. Percutaneous core-needle biopsy of enlarged lymph nodes in the diagnosis and subclassification of malignant lymphomas
. Eur Radiol
. 2001
;11
(2
):276
-283
.13.
Skelton
E
, Jewison
A
, Okpaluba
C
, et al. Image-guided core needle biopsy in the diagnosis of malignant lymphoma
. Eur J Surg Oncol
. 2015
;41
(7
):852
-858
.14.
Nguyen
BM
, Halprin
C
, Olimpiadi
Y
, Traum
P
, Yeh
JJ
, Dauphine
C
. Core needle biopsy is a safe and accurate initial diagnostic procedure for suspected lymphoma
. Am J Surg
. 2014
;208
(6
):1003
-1008
.15.
Ridder
GJ
, Pfeiffer
J
. Usefulness of cutting needle biopsy in recurrent and advanced staged head and neck malignancies in a palliative setting
. Support Care Cancer
. 2007
;15
(11
):1301
-1307
.16.
Screaton
NJ
, Berman
LH
, Grant
JW
. Head and neck lymphadenopathy: evaluation with US-guided cutting-needle biopsy
. Radiology
. 2002
;224
(1
):75
-81
.17.
Li
L
, Wu
QL
, Liu
LZ
, et al. Value of CT-guided core-needle biopsy in diagnosis and classification of malignant lymphomas using automated biopsy gun
. World J Gastroenterol
. 2005
;11
(31
):4843
-4847
.18.
Loubeyre
P
, McKee
TA
, Copercini
M
, Rosset
A
, Dietrich
P-Y
. Diagnostic precision of image-guided multisampling core needle biopsy of suspected lymphomas in a primary care hospital
. Br J Cancer
. 2009
;100
(11
):1771
-1776
.19.
Pugliese
N
, Di Perna
M
, Cozzolino
I
, et al. Randomized comparison of power Doppler ultrasonography-guided core-needle biopsy with open surgical biopsy for the characterization of lymphadenopathies in patients with suspected lymphoma
. Ann Hematol
. 2017
;96
(4
):627
-637
.20.
Kim
BM
, Kim
E-K
, Kim
MJ
, Yang
WI
, Park
CS
, Park
SI
. Sonographically guided core needle biopsy of cervical lymphadenopathy in patients without known malignancy
. J Ultrasound Med
. 2007
;26
(5
):585
-591
.21.
Pfeiffer
J
, Kayser
G
, Technau-Ihling
K
, Boedeker
CC
, Ridder
GJ
. Ultrasound-guided core-needle biopsy in the diagnosis of head and neck masses: indications, technique, and results
. Head Neck
. 2007
;29
(11
):1033
-1040
.22.
de Kerviler
E
, de Bazelaire
C
, Mounier
N
, et al. Image-guided core-needle biopsy of peripheral lymph nodes allows the diagnosis of lymphomas
. Eur Radiol
. 2007
;17
(3
):843
-849
.23.
Groneck
L
, Quaas
A
, Hallek
M
, Zander
T
, Weihrauch
MR
. Ultrasound-guided core needle biopsies for workup of lymphadenopathy and lymphoma
. Eur J Haematol
. 2016
;97
(4
):379
-386
.24.
Burke
C
, Thomas
R
, Inglis
C
, et al. Ultrasound-guided core biopsy in the diagnosis of lymphoma of the head and neck. A 9 year experience
. Br J Radiol
. 2011
;84
(1004
):727
-732
.25.
Assaf
N
, Nassif
S
, Tamim
H
, Bazarbachi
A
, Zaatari
G
, Chakhachiro
Z
. Diagnosing lymphoproliferative disorders using core needle biopsy versus surgical excisional biopsy: three-year experience of a reference center in Lebanon
. Clin Lymphoma Myeloma Leuk
. 2020
;20
(8
):e455
-e460
.26.
Lachar
WA
, Shahab
I
, Saad
AJ
. Accuracy and cost-effectiveness of core needle biopsy in the evaluation of suspected lymphoma: a study of 101 cases
. Arch Pathol Lab Med
. 2007
;131
(7
):1033
-1039
.27.
Chatani
S
, Hasegawa
T
, Kato
S
, et al. Image-guided core needle biopsy in the diagnosis of malignant lymphoma: comparison with surgical excision biopsy
. Eur J Radiol
. 2020
;127
:108990
.28.
Vandervelde
C
, Kamani
T
, Varghese
A
, Ramesar
K
, Grace
R
, Howlett
DC
. A study to evaluate the efficacy of image-guided core biopsy in the diagnosis and management of lymphoma—results in 103 biopsies
. Eur J Radiol
. 2008
;66
(1
):107
-111
.29.
Johl
A
, Lengfelder
E
, Hiddemann
W
, Klapper
W
. German Low-grade Lymphoma Study Group (GLSG). Core needle biopsies and surgical excision biopsies in the diagnosis of lymphoma-experience at the Lymph Node Registry Kiel
. Ann Hematol
. 2016
;95
(8
):1281
-1286
.30.
Park
YM
, Oh
KH
, Cho
J-G
, et al. Analysis of efficacy and safety of core-needle biopsy versus fine-needle aspiration cytology in patients with cervical lymphadenopathy and salivary gland tumour
. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg
. 2018
;47
(10
):1229
-1235
.31.
Allin
D
, David
S
, Jacob
A
, Mir
N
, Giles
A
, Gibbins
N
. Use of core biopsy in diagnosing cervical lymphadenopathy: a viable alternative to surgical excisional biopsy of lymph nodes?
. Ann R Coll Surg Engl
. 2017
;99
(3
):242
-244
.32.
Wilczynski
A
, Görg
C
, Timmesfeld
N
, et al. Value and diagnostic accuracy of ultrasound-guided full core needle biopsy in the diagnosis of lymphadenopathy: a retrospective evaluation of 793 cases
. J Ultrasound Med
. 2020
;39
(3
):559
-567
.33.
Ingersoll
KF
, Zhao
Y
, Harrison
GP
, Li
Y
, Yang
LH
, Wang
E
. Limited tissue biopsies and hematolymphoid neoplasms
. Am J Clin Pathol
. 2019
;152
(6
):782
-798
.34.
Dvorak
P
, Hoffmann
P
, Simkovic
M
, Jandura
J
, Nova
M
. Is percutaneous computed tomography-guided biopsy sufficient to establish indolent lymphoma transformation?
. Arch Med Sci
. 2019
;15
(6
):1443
-1453
.35.
Kwon
M
, Yim
C
, Baek
HJ
, et al. Ultrasonography-guided core needle biopsy of cervical lymph nodes for diagnosing head and neck lymphoma compared with open surgical biopsy: exploration for factors that shape diagnostic yield
. Am J Otolaryngol
. 2018
;39
(6
):679
-684
.36.
He
Y
, Ji
X
, Xie
Y
, et al. Clinical application of ultrasound-guided core needle biopsy with multiple punches in the diagnosis of lymphoma
. World J Surg Oncol
. 2015
;13
(1
):126
.37.
Novoa
E
, Gürtler
N
, Arnoux
A
, Kraft
M
. Role of ultrasound-guided core-needle biopsy in the assessment of head and neck lesions: a meta-analysis and systematic review of the literature
. Head Neck
. 2012
;34
(10
):1497
-1503
.38.
Amador-Ortiz
C
, Chen
L
, Hassan
A
, et al. Combined core needle biopsy and fine-needle aspiration with ancillary studies correlate highly with traditional techniques in the diagnosis of nodal-based lymphoma
. Am J Clin Pathol
. 2011
;135
(4
):516
-524
.39.
de Kerviler
E
, Benet
C
, Brière
J
, de Bazelaire
C
. Image-guided needle biopsy for diagnosis and molecular biology in lymphomas
. Best Pract Res Clin Haematol
. 2012
;25
(1
):29
-39
.40.
European Society of Medical Oncology
. ESMO Clinical Practice Guidelines: Haematological Malignancies
. Accessed 1 January 2009. Available at:http://www.esmo.org/Guidelines/Haematological-Malignancies.41.
Société Française d’Hématologie: SFH, Referentiel, 2009 [in French]
. Accessed 1 September 2021. Available at:https://sfh.hematologie.net.42.
Cuenca-Jimenez
T
, Chia
Z
, Desai
A
, et al. The diagnostic performance of ultrasound-guided core biopsy in the diagnosis of head and neck lymphoma: results in 226 patients
. Int J Oral Maxillofac Surg
. 2021
;50
(4
):431
-436
.43.
Xie
Y
, Jaffe
ES
. How I diagnose angioimmunoblastic T-cell lymphoma
. Am J Clin Pathol
. 2021
;156
(1
):1
-14
.44.
Hu
Q
, Naushad
H
, Xie
Q
, Al-Howaidi
I
, Wang
M
, Fu
K
. Needle-core biopsy in the pathologic diagnosis of malignant lymphoma showing high reproducibility among pathologists
. Am J Clin Pathol
. 2013
;140
(2
):238
-247
.© 2022 by The American Society of Hematology
2022
You do not currently have access to this content.
This feature is available to Subscribers Only
Sign In or Create an Account Close Modal