Acenocoumarol is the most efficient oral anticoagulant with the least variation of resistance among naturally occurring VKOR mutations.
Warfarin and fluindione are equipotent for anticoagulation control but have different mechanisms of action on VKOR inactivation.
Warfarin, acenocoumarol, phenprocoumon, and fluindione are commonly prescribed oral anticoagulants for the prevention and treatment of thromboembolic disorders. These anticoagulants function by impairing the biosynthesis of active vitamin K–dependent coagulation factors through the inhibition of vitamin K epoxide reductase (VKOR). Genetic variations in VKOR have been closely associated with the resistant phenotype of oral anticoagulation therapy. However, the relative efficacy of these anticoagulants, their mechanisms of action, and their resistance variations among naturally occurring VKOR mutations remain elusive. Here, we explored these questions using our recently established cell-based VKOR activity assay with the endogenous VKOR function ablated. Our results show that the efficacy of these anticoagulants on VKOR inactivation, from most to least, is: acenocoumarol > phenprocoumon > warfarin > fluindione. This is consistent with their effective clinical dosages for stable anticoagulation control. Cell-based functional studies of how each of the 27 naturally occurring VKOR mutations responds to these 4 oral anticoagulants indicate that phenprocoumon has the largest resistance variation (up to 199-fold), whereas the resistance of acenocoumarol varies the least (<14-fold). Cell-based kinetics studies show that fluindione appears to be a competitive inhibitor of VKOR, whereas warfarin is likely to be a mixed-type inhibitor of VKOR. The anticoagulation effect of these oral anticoagulants can be reversed by the administration of a high dose of vitamin K, apparently due to the existence of a different enzyme that can directly reduce vitamin K. These findings provide new insights into the selection of oral anticoagulants, their effective dosage management, and their mechanisms of anticoagulation.